Someone has committed the ultimate Sesame Street felony: Cookie Monster’s triple berry pie has vanished, and the only thing left behind is a whole lot of dramatic gasping. Elmo gasps! Zoe gasps! Cookie Monster gasps! Oscar does not gasp, mostly because he’s too busy pouting that no one touched his sardine pie. Shocking. Truly shocking.

If you love Knives Out and the Muppets, Forks Out is the dessert-fueled crossover you didn’t know you needed. Check it out!

[Via Neatorama]