"typically last more than 2 years"

Comparatively, though, for a couple of hundred bucks, you are getting a way better deal with the mp3 player.

A car lasts 10 years at top whack, on average, before you get a new one, say, and an mp3 player lasts 2 years on average (at least – I've had my 5G iPod for nearly 3 now), but:

Car price/5 > mp3 price.

So yes, my car analogy still adds up. You didn't take scale into account. Of course an mp3 player doesn't last nearly as long, but it doesn't cost nearly as much.

Yours falls apart, however. Most adults are intelligent enough to select their mp3 player without giving others the decision. And 95% still choose iPods.

I'm not an Apple fanboy – I have both a Mac mini and an MSI Wind and prefer the Wind for everyday life because I get to wander about the house with it. However, I simply understand that Apple isn't just selling a physical product – they are selling the technology used to put it together.

And what a brilliant technology it is. 95% of people think so, anyway.

“typically last more than 2 years”

Comparatively, though, for a couple of hundred bucks, you are getting a way better deal with the mp3 player.

A car lasts 10 years at top whack, on average, before you get a new one, say, and an mp3 player lasts 2 years on average (at least – I’ve had my 5G iPod for nearly 3 now), but:

Car price/5 > mp3 price.

So yes, my car analogy still adds up. You didn’t take scale into account. Of course an mp3 player doesn’t last nearly as long, but it doesn’t cost nearly as much.

Yours falls apart, however. Most adults are intelligent enough to select their mp3 player without giving others the decision. And 95% still choose iPods.

I’m not an Apple fanboy – I have both a Mac mini and an MSI Wind and prefer the Wind for everyday life because I get to wander about the house with it. However, I simply understand that Apple isn’t just selling a physical product – they are selling the technology used to put it together.

And what a brilliant technology it is. 95% of people think so, anyway.

“typically last more than 2 years”

Comparatively, though, for a couple of hundred bucks, you are getting a way better deal with the mp3 player.

A car lasts 10 years at top whack, on average, before you get a new one, say, and an mp3 player lasts 2 years on average (at least – I’ve had my 5G iPod for nearly 3 now), but:

Car price/5 > mp3 price.

So yes, my car analogy still adds up. You didn’t take scale into account. Of course an mp3 player doesn’t last nearly as long, but it doesn’t cost nearly as much.

Yours falls apart, however. Most adults are intelligent enough to select their mp3 player without giving others the decision. And 95% still choose iPods.

I’m not an Apple fanboy – I have both a Mac mini and an MSI Wind and prefer the Wind for everyday life because I get to wander about the house with it. However, I simply understand that Apple isn’t just selling a physical product – they are selling the technology used to put it together.

And what a brilliant technology it is. 95% of people think so, anyway.

What drives me crazy about the times we find ourselves is how many of these are going to sell. Kids want them because 'all the cool kids use iPod'. Actually if they have over 95% of the music player market, a lot of loser kids have them too. Probably more, since I think the ratio of coolness compared to normal and loser kids was significant.

And not only will the kids buy them (and by 'buy' I mean get their parents to buy them), their parents will get them too. Full-grown adults too lazy to do a little homework themselves take their 10 year-old's advice on what's the best out there.

My turn for a car analogy. Would you take your 10 year-old's word on which is the best car to own?

What drives me crazy about the times we find ourselves is how many of these are going to sell. Kids want them because ‘all the cool kids use iPod’. Actually if they have over 95% of the music player market, a lot of loser kids have them too. Probably more, since I think the ratio of coolness compared to normal and loser kids was significant.
And not only will the kids buy them (and by ‘buy’ I mean get their parents to buy them), their parents will get them too. Full-grown adults too lazy to do a little homework themselves take their 10 year-old’s advice on what’s the best out there.
My turn for a car analogy. Would you take your 10 year-old’s word on which is the best car to own?

They aren't Microsoft – they research, implement and produce each product itself and does so to a high quality.

Nothing wrong with that. Nobody has a problem when a car firm sells their car at a way higher price than the parts cost, so why they have that problem with Apple?

They aren’t Microsoft – they research, implement and produce each product itself and does so to a high quality.

Nothing wrong with that. Nobody has a problem when a car firm sells their car at a way higher price than the parts cost, so why they have that problem with Apple?